Strategies for Writing Tests for Existing Code and Incrementally Refactoring

Test Driven Development (TDD) is a software development approach that emphasizes writing tests before implementing the actual code. While TDD is often associated with writing tests for new features, it can also be applied to existing codebases for the purpose of refactoring and improving test coverage. In this article, we will explore strategies for writing tests for existing code and incrementally refactoring it.

Understand the Existing Codebase

Before writing tests for existing code, it is important to gain a thorough understanding of the codebase. Analyze the code and identify any potential areas that lack test coverage or have particularly complex or critical functionality. This will help you prioritize which parts of the code to test first.

Start with the Most Critical or Fragile Areas

When dealing with existing code, it is often beneficial to start writing tests for the most critical or fragile areas first. These areas are typically prone to bugs or are essential for the proper functioning of the system. By writing tests for these areas, you can gain confidence in the code's correctness and ensure that future refactoring does not introduce regressions.

Write Tests for Existing Features

Existing codebases usually contain a set of features that have been implemented. Writing tests for these features is a good starting point for creating a test suite. Identify the main functionality of each feature and write tests that cover the typical usage scenarios as well as edge cases. These tests will act as a safety net when refactoring the code and serve as documentation for the behavior of the existing features.

Test the Code's Edge Cases and Boundaries

One common pitfall when writing tests for existing code is to only focus on the happy path and overlook edge cases and boundary conditions. It is crucial to write tests that cover these scenarios as they often reveal hidden bugs or unexpected behavior. By systematically testing various input combinations and edge cases, you can ensure that the code handles all possible scenarios correctly.

Work Incrementally and Refactor in Small Steps

When refactoring existing code, it is best to work in small, incremental steps. Aiming for a complete rewrite of the codebase is often unrealistic and can introduce unnecessary risks. Instead, start by identifying small sections of the code that can be improved, write tests for that specific area, and refactor it. Continuously run the tests to ensure that the refactoring does not break existing functionality.

Use Code Coverage Tools

Code coverage tools can provide insights into the existing test coverage of your codebase. They generate reports indicating which parts of the code are covered by tests and which are not. By using these tools, you can identify areas that need additional tests and focus your efforts on those specific areas. Aim for a high code coverage percentage, but keep in mind that 100% coverage is not always possible or necessary.

Refactor In Parallel with Existing Tests

During the refactoring process, it is important to continuously run the existing tests to ensure that no regressions are introduced. Refactoring should not only improve the code structure but also maintain its correctness. If any existing tests fail during refactoring, it indicates that the code has been modified in a way that breaks its expected behavior. Address these failures immediately before continuing with further refactoring.


Writing tests for existing code and incrementally refactoring it can be a challenging but rewarding process. By understanding the codebase, prioritizing critical areas, writing tests for existing features, and testing edge cases, you can improve the quality and maintainability of your code. Remember to work incrementally, leverage code coverage tools, and continuously run tests to ensure that your refactoring efforts do not introduce regressions. With these strategies in place, you can confidently refactor and improve even the most complex codebases.

© NoobToMaster - A 10xcoder company